Prime Time Crime

Courts & Justice wrongfully convicted

 

Correct Corrections Canada

Courts

   

$13M for wrongful conviction

MONTREAL - Rejean Hinse, now 73, was wrongly implicated in the Dec. 14, 1961 armed robbery of a couple who lived in Mont-Laurier, Que.   (CTV)  

 

Dad lost kids due to bogus doctor

WHITBY, Ont. - A child custody battle is an ugly, twisted jungle at the best of times, but a Whitby father never stood a chance after family court accepted a disparaging assessment done by a man posing as a psychologist.  And ignored the one by the true PhD.  (QMI)  

 

'Police can't control the crime anymore'

PORT ALBERNI - A jeweller from Port Alberni, BC, who shot an armed robber five times is taking a public stand for stronger rights to bear arms in Canada.  "The police can't control the crime anymore," Dennis Galloway said.  (CBC)

 

Ostrowski free on bail

ROCKWOOD INSTITUTION - Frank Ostrowski, a Winnipeg man who has spent 23 years in jail for a murder he says he didn't commit, will be going home for Christmas after being released on bail.   (CBC)  

 

90 days

RED DEER - A central Alberta farmer, charged after he took the law into his own hands over two years ago during a robbery on his property, will serve a 90-day jail sentence on weekends.  Brian Knight was charged after he fired two shots at a thief as he attempted to flee Bashaw-area farm on a stolen quad in March of 2009.  (CTV)   MORE:  Famer who shot thief will go to jail   Farmer gets jail   Farmer who shot thief sentenced    Premier "feels for' farmer   You know the justice system is upside down    Brian Knight Legal Fund  

 

Tainted blood trial acquittals

TORONTO - An Ontario judge has acquitted all defendants in the tainted blood scandal, angering victims of the worst public health disaster in Canadian history.  (CTV)   PREVIOUS:  Accused in tainted blood trial exonerated    All acquitted in tainted blood scandal   Blood scandal   Krever Commission

Woman sues

EDMONTON - Under the "New Identities for Victims of Abuse" (NIVA), Jane Doe and her young daughter were able to change their names and create new identities, but they couldn't tell anyone about their new lives - including family, friends and colleagues.  (CBC)   PREVIOUS:  Canadian Resource Centre for Victims of Crime

 

Another 'swatting'

TORONTO - Police kicked down the door of a North Toronto apartment last month after a caller warned them about a "possible murder" taking place inside.   (CTV)   PREVIOUS:  Swatting   Hacker's latest taunt

 

'I wasn't guilty'

TORONTO - Forty years ago an Ontario jury heard that Maxine Ditchfield died from a blow to the head, a case backed up by expert medical testimony and the victim’s 8-year-old son. (Toronto Star)

 

Man sues province for $32M

OTTAWA - Robert Stewart, one of four men who spent more than 15 years in prison only to have the murder case against them fall apart is now suing the province for nearly $32 million, alleging Crown prosecutors and police knew they were relying on "false evidence" from key witnesses to convict him.  (Ottawa Citizen) 

 

Charges dropped

TORONTO - A 39-year-old Toronto woman who was accused of killing her infant daughter walked free yesterday after a court was told the charge was based on apparently nothing more than her own physical reactions in the aftermath of the child's death.    (Toronto Star)  PREVIOUS:   Mother charged   Mother charged  

 

No malice

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada says a Crown attorney who pressed a controversial sex-abuse case against two families of SK foster parents in the 1990s did not act in malice.  (Toronto Star)   JUDGMENT:  2009 SCC 51   SK pay $1.5M to Klassen & Kvello   Miazga malicious prosecution case   SK ritual abuse hoax

   

Protecting the lawful citizen

Shoplifters. Burglars. Home invaders. All too often, they are deemed “victims” of the very people they attack: peaceful law-abiding citizens, many quite literally minding their own business.  (National Post)  

Death of personal responsibility  

Citizen's arrest bill  

Shoplifter's arrest won't impact trial: Crown

Police let shoplifters go  

Shun those who steal  

Why is David Chen on trial?

TPS' problem  

CanCon in Toronto  

2 charges dropped

Victims' rights action committee

Fear of vigilantes  

Vigilante  

Charges dismissed  

Not guilty  

Citizen not guilty  

Shoplifter testifies against shopkeeper  

Citizen's arrest trial resumes

Grocer challenges Charter

Charter challenge

Cleared of kidnapping

Some charges dropped

Put thief on trial, not me

An arresting citizen

Minorities’ view of police worsens

Shop keeper charged

Change citizens' arrest law

   

New background check rules

TORONTO - New guidelines put out by the Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police are aimed at creating a province-wide standard on such incidents. The suggested guidelines would stop police services from including mental health-related interactions in the reports.   (CP) 

Police to seal records  

Draft report   

Mental Health hired PR firm to accelerate national movement on mental health  .pdf  

Psychiatric cases mishandled

Detainees with mental disorders

Mental illness in the workplace

Building Mentally Healthy Workplaces

   

Compensation

WINNIPEG - After spending much of his adult life in prison for a grisly murder he did not commit, Kyle Unger is now suing for compensation.   (CP)   MORE:  Charges dropped   Unger to get new trial   Hair strands don't belong to convicted

Acquittal

TORONTO - Anthony Hanemaayer pleaded guilty part way through his 1989 trial and was sentenced to two years less a day in jail.  (Toronto Star)   PREVIOUS:   Lawyer pans police interview   1 less thing for government to hid   Karla Homolka    Paul Bernardo

   

Veterans formally exonerated

Original Seattle PI sketches   SEATTLE - The Army formally apologized Saturday for the wrongful conviction of 28 black soldiers accused of rioting and lynching an Italian prisoner of war in Seattle more than six decades ago.   (Seattle PI)

PREVIOUS:   Veteran dies hours after apology   On American soil    Italian POW lynched on Aug. 14, 1944

Murder suspect suing

CALGARY - Investigators probing the 1999 killing of Gail Foley had "tunnel vision," alleges a $10-million malicious prosecution lawsuit launched by the man who was considered the prime suspect.  Scott Allan McLaughlin was initially found guilty of second-degree murder, but the Alberta Court of Appeal overturned the conviction.  (Calgary Herald)

   

Inquiry report released

SASKATOON - The long-awaited report of the Commission of Inquiry into the wrongful conviction of David Milgaard cleared Saskatoon police, the RCMP, Crown prosecutors and federal justice officials of wrongdoing, saying they acted in good faith.  (Saskatoon Star Phoenix) 

David Milgaard

Milgaard inquiry

$11.6M inquiry finds no wrong doing

Final evidence heard at Milgaard inquiry

Milgaard advocates for the wrongfully convicted

   

Ex-prosecutor's cases questioned

WINNIPEG - An experienced Ontario judge who is one of Canada's most respected legal scholars has been retained to review the cases of former top Manitoba prosecutor George Dangerfield. . (Winnipeg Free Press)

Clerical errors blamed for wrongful arrests

VANCOUVER - More than a dozen people in BC have been wrongfully arrested or imprisoned in recent years because of clerical errors by court staff, according to internal government records.   (Vancouver Sun) 

   

Faith in justice system shaken

AMSTERDAM - Fallout from the case of the man wrongfully convicted of the murder of Nienke Kleiss, 10, in Schiedam has shaken the public's faith in the legal system in the Netherlands.  (Expatica)   MORE:  Leaked memo is not a confession, prosecutors insist    Prosecution denies hiding evidence in murder case

Crown admits flaws with O'Neill warrants

OTTAWA - A Crown attorney admitted in court on Wednesday that there were flaws in the warrants used to carry out a raid against Ottawa Citizen reporter Juliet O'Neill.  (CanWest)   PREVIOUS:  Reporter threatened during RCMP raid   Anti-terrorism law unconstitutional, newspaper lawyer argues   Injusticebusters: Juliet O'Neill

Charges dropped

OTTAWA - Crown prosecutors have withdrawn a murder charge against Romeo Phillion.  (CBC)   Romeo Phillion

Cop can't recall details

Background:  Romeo Phillion

Osgoode Hall Innocence Project:  Phillion

Blaming one cop 'a scandal'

QUEBEC - A lobby group that defends the wrongfully convicted said yesterday it is scandalous that one police officer is taking the fall for the entire justice system that sent Simon Marshall, a mentally disabled man, to prison for five years for sex crimes he didn't commit.  (Ottawa Citizen)

   

Medical examiner review

CALGARY - A provincial review has overturned a conclusion of a former Calgary medical examiner in a case involving a toddler’s death.  The two-year-old’s mother said family members were informed by the province and police that Dr. Michael Belenky’s initial finding of a “non-accidental” death has been changed to “accidental” following the review.  (Calgary Herald)  

Botched autopsy

12 reports flagged

Not certified  

Potential trial delays  

One word sparks review  

Forensic pathologist's files under review  

Pathologist's reports probed  

Work probed

   

Mother cleared

OSHAWA - After 13 years in prison for a murder that never happened, Tammy Marquardt was finally cleared of killing her young son.   (QMI)  

Charge dropped  

Crown withdrawals charge  

Father exonerated

Conviction dropped  

Conviction quashed

No compensation

Mother acquitted

Mother free on bail

Freedom after 14 years  

Man acquitted

'No contest'

'No contest' plea  

Licence revoked 

Charles Randal Smith   

Wrongful-conviction compensation 

$13M lawsuit

William (Bill) Mullins-Johnson

Court removes 'scarlet letter'

Acquittal and apology for Mullins-Johnson

Mullins-Johnson acquitted

injusticebusters: William Mullins-Johnson

The Regulators

   

Latimer to be released on parole

VANCOUVER - In a surprise reversal, Robert Latimer, the Saskatchewan farmer jailed for the 1993 killing of his severely disabled daughter, Tracy, is being released on day parole after seven years' imprisonment. .  (CanWest)

Latimer's legal crusade hurt chance for parole

Latimer parole decision

National Parole Board

'Cruel & unusual': The law and Latimer

Robert Latimer: news & web links

   

$13M for wrongful conviction

TORONTO - A $13M malicious prosecution and negligence lawsuit filed by Robert Baltovich takes aim at a sacred cow - a respected former prosecutor who is now a judge - as well as Toronto police and two former defence lawyers.   (Toronto Star)

Baltovich sues

Robert Baltovich 

Not guilty

Baltovich says he never lost hope

Baltovich 'just glad it's over'

Baltovich acquitted of murder

Robert Baltovich Timeline

injusticebusters: Baltovich

Truscott awarded $6.5M

TORONTO - Steven Truscott, who was sentenced to hang in 1959 at age 14 for a murder he did not commit, will receive $6.5 million in compensation from the Ontario government.  (Toronto Star)

Question of compensation for Truscott

Weighing the trauma endured by a 14-year-old

Province on hook for high price of justice

Truscott acquitted

Cost mounting for 'very expensive lesson'

Wrongfully convicted call for overhaul to reviews

NL man awarded $2M for wrongful conviction

Insect evidence opens new line

Truscott review hears grisly evidence

Truscott bears no ill will to investigator

Truscott case autopsy notes never received

Case may turn on a worm

Pathologist's work could add to wrongly accused

Statement analysis: Steven Truscott

Last Seen With

Steven Truscot's Long Ride Into History

His word against history

NB settlement

FREDERICTON - The New Brunswick government has reached an out-of-court settlement with Erin Michael Walsh over his wrongful conviction for second-degree murder in 1975. (CBC)

Murder conviction overturned

Dying man granted acquittal

If justice fails

Jury overturns conviction

Man jailed for rape Bernardo admits to

Driskell inquiry Commission

Injustice Busters: James Driskell

Center on Wrongful Convictions

CBC Indepth: Wrongfully convicted

Jailed for murders they didn't commit

Legal aid in Canada

Legal aid system is flawed

Justice officials knew of injustices

Dirty secrets emerge

Was the wrong man hanged?

Inaccuracies left Justice officials doubting claims

Man freed after 10 extra years in jail

Ont. man convicted of murder granted bail

Prime Time Crime

Recent Headlines